The comparison of turbine flowmeter, orifice flowmeter and ultrasonic flowmeter - Just Measure it

The comparison of turbine flowmeter, orifice flowmeter and ultrasonic flowmeter

Turbine flowmeters are widely used. They can be used in measuring instruments for trade settlement of crude oil, natural gas, and valuable fluids, and can also be used in product production process control, as the feedback signal provider and controller of the control system.

Turbine flowmeter has high accuracy, especially good repeatability, so it has the characteristics of a standard flowmeter as a standard meter flow device and can be used as a standard meter or as a standard for periodical verification of a flow standard device. International and domestic value comparisons often use turbine flowmeters as transmission standards.

ZeroInstrument
The applications of turbine flow meters are summarized as follows:
(1) Trade measurement: natural gas transmission and distribution network, urban natural gas, etc.
(2) Process control: petrochemical, electric power, industrial boilers, etc.
(3) The standard device is used as a standard meter. Generally, the accuracy level is not less than 0.2. The comparison of the turbine flowmeter, orifice flowmeter, and ultrasonic flowmeter is shown in Table 2-2.

ZeroInstrument

 

Compare items Orifice flowmeter Turbine flowmeter Ultrasonic flowmeter
Max flowrate m3*h-1 ≤100000 ≤25000 ≤200000
Maximum turndown ratio 5:1 20/30 :1 150:1
Laboratory accuracy ±(1~2)% ±(0.5~1)% ±(0.5~2)%
Pressure loss Big Small Small
Pulsating flow measurement No Yes None
Flow velocity distribution influence Sensitive Not Sensitive Sensitive
Front straight pipe requirements (30-100)D (2-5)D (10-30)D
Influence of medium temperature Big Small Small
Influence of medium humidity Big Small Small
Influence of medium density Severe Small Small
Influence of medium composition Severe None None
Operating cost price High Middle Low
Price Middle Middle High
Advantages Suitable for large flow,
high precision
Suitable for various
flow ranges
The pressure loss is small,
and the influence of temperature and
pressure on the measurement is minimal
Disadvantages The hole is easy to wear and
requires high-precision accessory equipment
There are moving parts in the meter,
which are easy to wear
The size is limited to more than DN80,
which is more sensitive to the flow field, and the dirt on the probe will cause errors
Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Contact Us

    Please prove you are human by selecting the car.